The Effects of Metal Coatings on Welding Fumes

Metal coatings, which enhance the function and durability of metal products, can significantly modify the composition of welding fumes.

This piece examines ten prevalent metal coatings, discussing their properties and the hazards associated with their fumes to provide a crucial perspective on an often-neglected facet of welding safety.

Galvanized (Zinc) Coating

Method Overview: Galvanization involves applying a zinc layer to steel or iron, commonly by immersing the metal in molten zinc, known as hot-dip galvanizing. This zinc coating acts as a protective barrier and provides cathodic protection, meaning it corrodes in place of the metal beneath, thereby protecting it.

Benefits and Usage: Galvanizing’s primary benefit is its superior resistance to corrosion, significantly increasing the lifespan of metal structures and components, especially in environments prone to moisture and salt, like outdoor or marine settings. Moreover, galvanizing is cost-effective compared to other coatings and demands little upkeep.

Effect on Welding Emissions: Welding galvanized metals leads to the vaporization of the zinc coating at high temperatures, creating zinc oxide fumes. Inhalation of these fumes can result in metal fume fever, a temporary, flu-like condition marked by symptoms such as chills, fever, and muscle pains.

Find out more about the fumes from welding galvanized steel here.

Anodizing (Aluminum)

Process Overview: Anodizing, an electrochemical technique, enhances metal (usually aluminum) surfaces to create a decorative, corrosion-resistant, and durable oxide finish. It involves immersing metal parts in an acid electrolyte bath and applying an electrical current, thickening the natural oxide layer.

Benefits and Applications: Anodizing boosts corrosion and wear resistance and improves adhesion for paints and glues. It’s also popular for its aesthetic appeal, as the metal can be colored.

Effect on Welding Emissions: Welding anodized aluminum primarily raises concerns about aluminum oxide particle release. Additionally, if the anodizing includes colored dyes or additives, these may break down under intense heat, releasing potentially harmful fumes.

Powder Coating

Process Overview: Powder coating, a dry finishing method, involves applying a finely ground mixture of pigment and resin to a metal surface using electrostatic forces, followed by heat curing to form a solid, protective layer. This technique results in a uniform, durable, and high-quality finish.

Benefits and Applications: Preferred for its robustness, cost-effectiveness, and eco-friendliness, powder coating is an excellent alternative to traditional paint. It’s free from solvents, releases minimal VOCs, and offers a consistent finish in various colors and textures.

Effect on Welding Emissions: Although powder coating is safer regarding VOCs during application, welding can decompose the coating, possibly emitting various compounds depending on the powder’s makeup, including organic substances from the resin. These fumes can irritate the respiratory system and eyes.

Painted Coating

Method Overview: Painting a metal involves applying paint via brushing, spraying, or dipping. Paint typically contains color pigments, binders, solvents, and additives, each serving purposes like UV resistance, drying time, and flexibility.

Benefits and Usage: Paint coatings are chosen for their visual appeal, offering a range of colors and finishes. Besides aesthetics, they protect against corrosion, moisture, and chemical exposure, and can be tailored for specific requirements like heat resistance, electrical insulation, or enhanced robustness.

Effect on Welding Emissions: Welding painted surfaces can release hazardous chemicals, depending on the paint’s composition. Older paints may contain lead, creating a risk of poisoning. Other paints might emit toxic fumes from burning components, including pigments, binders, solvents, and additives. The release of Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) is a significant concern, as these fumes can irritate the respiratory system and eyes, and prolonged exposure can cause substantial health problems, affecting the liver, kidneys, or central nervous system.

Plating (Chrome, Nickel, etc.)

Process Explanation: Plating, which deposits a thin metal layer (like chrome or nickel) onto another metal, is achieved through electroplating or similar methods. This enhances the metal’s appearance, boosts its corrosion resistance, and reduces wear resistance and friction.

Advantages and Usage: Popular for its decorative shine and attractive finish, plating also offers functional benefits, including increased corrosion resistance, surface hardness, and durability. Chrome and nickel plating are widely used in automotive, aerospace, and consumer goods industries.

Impact on Welding Emissions: Welding plated materials, especially chrome or nickel, can release harmful chromium and nickel fumes. Chromium, particularly in its hexavalent form, is carcinogenic. Nickel fumes can cause metal fume fever, respiratory problems, skin irritation, and even cancer.

Epoxy Coatings

Process Explanation: Epoxy coatings, composed of epoxy resin and a hardener, are applied to metal surfaces, forming a durable, chemical-resistant layer. Curing is a chemical reaction between the resin and hardener, creating a solid bond with the metal.

Advantages and Usage: Known for excellent adhesion, high mechanical and thermal resistance, and superior chemical resistance, epoxy coatings are used in harsh chemical, abrasion, and corrosion environments, such as industrial settings, pipelines, and automotive applications.

Impact on Welding Emissions: When subjected to welding heat, epoxy coatings can decompose, releasing various organic compounds (VOCs). These fumes can irritate the respiratory system, nose, throat, and eyes, and prolonged or intense exposure could lead to asthma or more severe health risks.

Chromate Coating

Process Overview: Applied to metals like aluminum, zinc, steel, and magnesium, chromate coatings enhance corrosion resistance, improve paint adhesion, and add a decorative touch. The process involves applying a chromate conversion coating, forming a gel-like layer on the metal surface.

Benefits and Applications: This coating is valuable for its corrosion resistance, maintenance of electrical conductivity, and utility as a primer for additional paint or coatings. It’s extensively used in industries like aerospace, automotive, and electronics.

Effect on Welding Emissions: The main concern with welding chromate-coated metals is the potential release of chromium compounds, particularly hexavalent chromium, a highly toxic and carcinogenic substance. Welding heat can convert trivalent chromium in the coating to hexavalent chromium in the fumes.

Phosphate Coating

Process Overview: Phosphate coating involves treating metals like steel, aluminum, or silver with a solution of zinc, iron, or manganese phosphate. The process, involving phosphoric acid and metal salts, can be done via immersion or spraying.

Advantages and Applications: Used primarily for enhancing paint adhesion and corrosion resistance, phosphate coatings also create an ideal surface for lubricants, making them suitable for frequently lubricated metal parts. They’re commonly used in automotive, military, appliance, and machinery manufacturing.

Impact on Welding Emissions: Welding phosphate-coated materials can release various phosphate compounds. Though less hazardous than zinc or chromium compounds, phosphates can irritate the respiratory tract.

Thermal Spraying

Process Explanation: Thermal spraying involves applying molten or semi-molten materials (metals, alloys, ceramics, or plastics) onto a surface to create a coating. It allows for thicker coatings and higher deposition rates than electroplating and can be done by various methods like plasma, flame, wire arc, and detonation spraying.

Advantages and Usage: Used for wear resistance, corrosion protection, thermal insulation, and restoring dimensions of worn parts, thermal spraying extends component life, enhances performance in harsh conditions, and repairs damage.

Impact on Welding Emissions: Fumes from thermal spraying and subsequent welding vary based on the coating materials. Metal coatings might produce metal fumes, whereas ceramic or plastic coatings could emit different chemical compounds at high welding temperatures.

Sherardizing (Zinc Thermal Diffusion)

Process Overview: Sherardizing is a technique where ferrous components are coated with zinc dust and heated in a sealed environment. This leads to the diffusion of zinc into the surface, creating a uniform zinc-iron alloy layer, even on intricate shapes.

Advantages and Applications: The primary use of sherardizing is to provide corrosion resistance. It’s particularly effective for small parts and complex shapes where achieving a uniform coating is challenging.

Impact on Welding Emissions: Similar to galvanizing, sherardizing can emit zinc oxide fumes during welding, which may cause metal fume fever and other respiratory issues upon inhalation.

Conclusion

Grasping the intricacies of metal coatings and their influence on welding fumes is vital for maintaining welding quality and welder safety. Each coating brings unique advantages, such as improved corrosion resistance and aesthetics, but also poses specific challenges regarding the generated welding fumes.

Removing any coating from the area to be welded is often advisable, extending a few inches beyond the weld. This should be done safely, following supplier instructions to avoid other health risks for workers.

For a more comprehensive approach to managing welding fumes, we recommend exploring our detailed “8-Step Method to Manage Welding Fume.” This guide provides practical steps and insights for creating a safer welding environment.

Any Questions?

Feel free to contact us. We will help you protect your workers and comply with welding fumes standards anywhere in the US and Canada.

1-866-800-8421
info@airgomig.com